#stillbreathing, #thinkdifferently, #youarewhatyoudo

Opinions… and When It Is Appropriate (or Not) to Give Them

Posted by meggles83

We are asked for opinions throughout our entire lives.

What should I do?
What do you think?
Should I stay or go?
Should I take the job?
Should I risk it?
Should I speak up?
Am I failing?
Am I succeeding?

And if we are honest, we don’t always wait to be asked. We volunteer opinions too. Freely. Quickly. Sometimes confidently. Sometimes carelessly. Sometimes from love. Sometimes from ego. Sometimes because we believe we know better.

Opinions are everywhere.

But the older I get, the more I believe this truth:

Opinions are powerful. And because they are powerful, they should be handled carefully.

Not Every Opinion Is Wisdom

Some opinions are grounded in lived experience, humility, scars, reflection, and empathy.

Others are built on assumptions.

Some come from people who have walked through the fire.

Others come from people who have only watched it from a distance.

There is a difference.

And that difference matters most in the places that shape us deeply: relationships and work.

Because in both arenas, people are quick to weigh in.

Who you should love.
What you should tolerate.
What success should look like.
How fast you should rise.
What title should define you.
When you should leave.
What mistakes should disqualify you.

The world is full of commentary on lives it has never lived.

Relationships Taught Me This First

Recently, someone said to me, “We shouldn’t be asked our opinion or advice on relationships.” It caught me off guard.

Not because relationships are simple – they are anything but. But because relationships are often where our deepest lessons are learned.

I have lived a lot of life in relationships. I have failed. I have loved deeply. I have gone through divorce as a child and later as an adult with children of my own. I have experienced heartbreak, rebuilding, grief, growth, and the painful process of relearning who I actually was beneath everyone else’s expectations.

And through all of that, I found something I did not know I was capable of finding: Myself.

And once I found myself, I found a kind of love I did not realize I deserved.

So no – I do not believe no one should give opinions on relationships.

I believe we should be careful how we give them.

Work Taught Me This Too

The same is true professionally.

Over the years, I have had successes people applauded and failures people whispered about.

Wins people wanted to attach themselves to.
Losses people wanted to define me by.

Moments where everyone had an opinion on what I should do next, what I should have done differently, or what my story “meant.”

And at times, I listened too much.

I let external voices narrate chapters that belonged to me.

Then one person said something I have never forgotten:

“Share your story on lessons learned…but do not call them failures. And do not let someone else tell your narrative. It is part of your journey and made you the executive you are today.”

That changed me.

Because some seasons are not failures.
They are education.
They are refinement.
They are resilience training.
They are the making of leadership.

Not every setback deserves the label others assign to it.

When Opinions Become Dangerous

Opinions become dangerous when they are given:

  • Without listening
  • Without context
  • Without humility
  • Without understanding the emotional or professional weight someone is carrying
  • Without acknowledging that your path is not their path
  • Without recognizing your own bias, fear, or insecurity

Sometimes advice says more about the giver than the receiver.

“You should have stayed.”
“You should have left sooner.”
“You’ll never find better.”
“You missed your shot.”
“You peaked already.”
“You failed.”
“You’re behind.”

These statements can land like truth when someone is vulnerable.

But they may simply be projections.

How Opinions Shaped Me

Growing up, I listened to many opinions.

I let them shape me.

At times, I stopped trusting my own gut. I ignored the inner fire inside me because it felt easier to follow what everyone else believed was “right.”

Personally, I wanted to please everyone.
Professionally, I wanted to prove myself to everyone.

I wanted to be the woman who did it all perfectly.

But in trying to satisfy expectations that were never fully mine, I created wounds of my own.

I had to spend years unwinding patterns that did not belong to me. And let’s be honest…I am still learning that daily…

I had to learn the power of “No.” Still working on that. The power of boundaries. The power of disappointing others in order to stop abandoning myself. The power of defining success for myself.

When Opinions Are a Gift

Opinions can absolutely be valuable.

Sometimes one honest sentence changes a life.

Sometimes someone sees clearly when we cannot.

Sometimes wisdom borrowed from another person helps us survive our next step.

But the best opinions are offered like this:

  • Gently
  • With permission
  • With curiosity
  • With compassion
  • With awareness that you may not know the full story
  • With room for the other person to choose differently

The healthiest advice often sounds like:

  • “Would you like my honest perspective?”
  • “I may not understand everything, but here’s what I see.”
  • “This is what helped me, but your path may be different.”
  • “This chapter does not define you.”
  • “What does your gut already know?”
  • “I trust you to decide what’s best for you.”

That is wisdom with humility.

Before Giving an Opinion, Ask Yourself:

  1. Have I truly listened?
  2. Am I speaking from experience or assumption?
  3. Am I trying to help—or trying to control?
  4. Is this about them, or about my own fears?
  5. Was I invited to speak?
  6. Can I offer truth without certainty?

Before Receiving an Opinion, Ask Yourself:

  1. Has this person lived anything close to what I’m navigating?
  2. Do they know me deeply—or only my situation superficially?
  3. Do they want what’s best for me, or what makes sense to them?
  4. Does their advice create clarity…or confusion?
  5. What is my own inner voice saying?

Final Thought

Advice is a gift…just like feedback is a gift.

But gifts should be chosen thoughtfully and given with care.

Because words can guide people toward freedom…or away from themselves.

So yes, keep sharing wisdom. Keep helping others. Keep loving people enough to speak truth.

But remember:

Not every opinion needs to be spoken.
Not every opinion needs to be followed.
Not every setback is failure.
Not every success needs outside validation.

And sometimes the wisest voice in the room is the quiet one inside you.

Related Post

1 Comment

  1. Jim McNeese

    Another amazing Blog Babe. I proud of who you are and who you continue to grow into. Love you

Leave A Comment